What happened: Rhyker Earl, a 26-year-old Indiana man with a history of seizures, died after a call for emergency assistance escalated into a fatal incident involving law enforcement. Earl, who was postictal after a seizure, reportedly fell into a police officer during EMS evaluation. The officer restrained Earl in a prone position, while EMS administered sedatives. He became unresponsive and was transported to the hospital, where he was later taken off life support. The investigation continues into the factors that led to his death, with a focus on the combination of prone restraint and sedative use.
| More: Ind. county sheriff denies restraint claims before patient’s death
Highlights
Watch as Ed Bauter, MBA, MHL, NRP, FP-C, CCP-C; and Daniel Schwester, MICP, highlight the significance of this development, including:
- Prone restraint lasting 15 minutes. Earl was restrained in a prone position for approximately 15 minutes, which is known to be a high-risk maneuver, especially for individuals with respiratory issues.
- Sedation administered while restrained. EMS gave three doses of sedatives, though the specific drug has not been confirmed. Sedation while a patient is in a prone position adds another layer of danger.
- Family discovered patient not breathing. Earl’s family noticed he was not breathing while still in the prone position, a traumatic moment that adds to the concerns over how long appropriate medical intervention was delayed.
The path forward
This tragic case underscores the importance of EMS taking decisive action when patients are in dangerous positions, even when law enforcement is involved. EMS personnel must prioritize patient safety, particularly during prolonged prone restraints, which are well-documented as potentially life-threatening. With courts increasingly holding EMS accountable in such incidents, the profession must focus on education, clearer protocols and assertive patient advocacy to prevent future deaths.
| More: Prone positioning: Therapy or apathy?
EMS1 is using generative AI to create some content that is edited and fact-checked by our editors.
